“Judge not, that ye be not judged.” (Bible Matthew 7.1, KJV) I grew up with a very simplistic take on these words: If you judge people, God will judge you.
Pretty scary, especially when it’s very human to have uncharitable, unfriendly thoughts about people that we meet every day.
So I accepted the verse in a fatalistic way. I was going to be judged, because I did judge other people. Other than trying not to, I didn’t see what I could do about it. I tried to push the whole thing away.
But over the last few years, the phrase started intruding on my consciousness. It demanded to be recognized as something more than a…judgmental…pronouncement. I’ve come to believe that it’s a description of the way things are.
As I said above, I have a problem with judgmentalism. I say it’s a problem because a) I don’t think spending time judging others is healthy and b) I think I probably do it more than most. It likely stems from a defensiveness born of bullying, but that’s a whole different story.
“What kind of person thinks these things?”I find myself mentally criticizing people. Random people. On the subway going to work, I may judge someone by their book, their coat, their hair, their laughter, their inability to move to the center of the car… Some days I’m shocked by my own harshness and ask “What kind of person thinks these things?”
After spending some time with the question, I realized that I was pre-empting their criticism of me. Because if someone thought I was ugly, it wouldn’t count because she had bad hair. Or if he didn’t like my shoes, it didn’t matter because he was obviously shallow.
The phrase “Do not judge, and you will not be judged” kept coming to me as I thought about my judgmentalism. At first, I thought it was just another guilt trip. Eventually I began to see something much deeper.
Putting “Judge Not” in a New Light
On the days when I’m engrossed in my book and don’t even pay attention to the people around me, I never worry about being judged. The need to defend myself doesn’t even cross my mind. And on days when I do judge the people around me, I never start by thinking “Oh, she’s judging me,” I make a preemptive judgment about her just in case.
“Judge not” describes the circle that forms once I get started. If I’m mentally criticizing people, it only makes me feel insecure and defensive, so I do it even more. The longer I keep it up, the easier it is for me to imagine that everyone on the train is evil and hates me. Which is ridiculous because they probably haven’t even noticed me. Odds are that most of them are decent people like me, imperfect but perfectly human.
If I’m not judging, I don’t feel judged at all.
So what happens if we don’t take that as a pronouncement and instead as a description?
Then, instead of condemning us for every time we think something unkind, this saying gently reminds us that when we judge others, we open ourselves up at least to feel judged as well. But by refraining from making negative judgments about others, we feel less paranoid about our relationships with friends and strangers and open ourselves up to more possibilities.
If you do not judge others, you will worry less about being judged by them.
“Do not judge, and you will not be judged; do not condemn, and you will not be condemned. Forgive, and you will be forgiven” (Luke 6.37, NRSV)